NewsStocksRailways Declares Fare Calculation Methodology a 'Trade Secret', CIC Dismisses RTI AppealRailways Declares Fare Calculation Methodology a 'Trade Secret', CIC Dismisses RTI Appeal
Indian Railways successfully defended its fare calculation methodology as a trade secret before the Central Information Commission, which dismissed an RTI appeal seeking detailed pricing information. The Railway Board cited Section 8 of the RTI Act and previous CIC orders to justify non-disclosure, arguing that fare fixation policies constitute intellectual property rights and that detailed pricing disclosure is not in public interest.
*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
The Indian Railways has declared its passenger train fare calculation methodology as confidential commercial information, successfully defending against an RTI appeal seeking transparency in pricing mechanisms. The Central Information Commission (CIC) has dismissed the application, upholding the Railways' position on maintaining secrecy around fare determination processes.
RTI Appeal Details and Railway Board Response
The dismissed RTI application had sought comprehensive information about the Railways' fare calculation system, including details on base fare mechanisms, dynamic pricing implementation, and the impact of Tatkal bookings on ticket prices. The appellant specifically requested information related to the Paschim Superfast Express service's pricing structure.
| RTI Request Components: | Details |
|---|---|
| Base Fare Calculation: | Detailed methodology sought |
| Dynamic Pricing: | Implementation and impact analysis |
| Tatkal Bookings: | Effect on overall fare structure |
| Specific Service: | Paschim Superfast Express |
The Railway Board's Chief Public Information Officer (CPIO) responded by invoking Section 8 of the RTI Act, which provides exemptions for sensitive information disclosure. The Railways maintained that fare charging operates on a class-based system with variations arising from different facilities provided across passenger classes.
Trade Secret and Commercial Confidence Claims
In its official reply accessed by PTI, the Railway Board stated that "the policy mechanism falls in the domain of trade secret/intellectual property rights" regarding fare classification and fixation methodology. The Railways emphasized that this information is exempt from disclosure under Section 8 of the RTI Act, which protects sensitive data including national security matters, trade secrets, and personal privacy information.
Railway officials referenced previous CIC orders that had supported non-disclosure of pricing methodologies, arguing that Indian Railways operates as a commercial utility while simultaneously fulfilling social obligations in the national interest. The organization highlighted its dual role as both a commercial enterprise and a state instrumentality responsible for various social functions.
Public Interest and Commercial Utility Arguments
The Railway Board CPIO argued that detailed pricing mechanism disclosure was not justified in public interest. The Railways distinguished its operations from private enterprises by stating: "Disclosure of pricing related information is not justified in public interest, as profit, if any, is distributed/transferred to common man and is not retained for the benefit of personal gain as in the case of private enterprise."
| Railway Board Arguments: | Justification |
|---|---|
| Commercial Utility: | Operates as business entity |
| Social Obligations: | Serves national interest |
| Profit Distribution: | Benefits transferred to public |
| Trade Secret Protection: | Intellectual property rights |
CIC Decision and Final Disposition
Information Commissioner Swagat Das noted that the public information officer had already provided all disclosable information and general principles of railway rating policies. The Commission determined that the Railways was not required to create or interpret data beyond available records.
Finding no procedural irregularities in the Railway Board's response and noting the appellant's absence during the hearing, Commissioner Das concluded that no further intervention was necessary. The CIC disposed of the appeal, effectively maintaining the Railways' position on fare calculation confidentiality.
The decision reinforces the Railways' ability to protect its pricing methodologies under trade secret provisions while continuing to operate as both a commercial entity and public service provider. The ruling establishes precedent for similar future RTI requests seeking detailed fare calculation information from Indian Railways.
19
