India set for cyclical earnings upswing, may outperform EM peers despite valuation concerns: Jonathan Garner, Morgan Stanley
Morgan Stanley's Jonathan Garner forecasts a cyclical earnings recovery for India with mid-to-high teens growth over the next two years, compared to 5.00-7.00% in the year just ended. The anticipated upswing is driven by RBI monetary easing, improving regulatory conditions, and capex revival. Despite valuation concerns, Indian equities at 18.00 times forward earnings show compressed premiums versus emerging markets. Morgan Stanley remains overweight on financials, industrials and consumer discretionary while cautious on IT services due to AI uncertainties.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
India is entering a cyclical earnings recovery that could see it outperform most emerging markets over the next two years, even as concerns persist around valuations and foreign investor outflows, according to Jonathan Garner, Chief Asia & Emerging Market Strategist and Chairman of Asset Allocation at Morgan Stanley.
Earnings Growth Acceleration Expected
Speaking to ET Now, Garner highlighted that Indian earnings growth has been weaker than widely assumed, creating room for a significant rebound. The Morgan Stanley strategist revealed that broad market earnings growth has been closer to 5.00-7.00% for the Sensex in the year just ended, setting the stage for improvement.
| Metric | Current Performance | Forecast |
|---|---|---|
| Sensex Earnings Growth | 5.00-7.00% (year ended) | Mid-to-high teens |
| Performance vs EM | Below average | Likely to exceed EM overall |
| Timeframe | - | Next two years |
"We now see a cyclical upswing coming, with mid- to high-teens earnings growth over the next two years," Garner said, adding that this would likely exceed earnings growth across emerging markets overall.
Valuation Concerns Ease on Forward Metrics
Addressing concerns that India's growth is already priced in, Garner noted that valuation premiums have narrowed sharply. Based on a two-year forward target of 95,000.00 for the Sensex, Indian equities are trading at around 18.00 times forward earnings, compared with roughly 13.00 times for emerging markets in aggregate.
"At the peak, India was trading at nearly twice EM valuations. That gap has compressed meaningfully," he explained. Despite sustained foreign institutional investor outflows, dedicated emerging market funds are now slightly underweight India—the most negative positioning in nearly a decade, which could set up potential for flow reversals if the earnings cycle turns.
Policy Support and Capex Revival Drive Recovery
Garner attributed the anticipated earnings upswing to multiple domestic factors that are aligning favorably:
- Monetary easing by the Reserve Bank of India
- Improving regulatory conditions
- Early signs of revival in the capital expenditure cycle
- Inflation tracking below 2.00%, creating room for policy support
He acknowledged that nominal GDP growth has been weak despite strong real GDP growth, but emphasized that low inflation provides scope for policy support measures.
Fiscal Position Remains Strong
On fiscal risks ahead of the Union Budget, Garner said India is likely to pursue modest fiscal consolidation, targeting a deficit of around 4.20% of GDP. He described India's macro position as "very strong," citing:
| Parameter | Status |
|---|---|
| Current Account | Stable |
| Foreign Exchange Reserves | Healthy |
| Currency Position | Trading below real effective exchange rate trend |
| Fiscal Deficit Target | ~4.20% of GDP |
"These factors make India an interesting and relatively resilient story in a very uncertain global environment," Garner noted.
Sector Preferences and Investment Strategy
Within Indian equities, Morgan Stanley maintains an overweight position on financials, industrials and consumer discretionary stocks. Garner highlighted India's young and urbanising population as continuing to support modern consumption patterns, making it "somewhat unique among large global economies."
However, the firm expressed caution on IT services stocks, citing uncertainty around how artificial intelligence adoption could affect traditional revenue models. "IT services is not a sector we are particularly enthusiastic about at this stage," he said.
Within financials, Morgan Stanley prefers private sector banks and non-bank financial companies over PSU banks, highlighting potential for AI-led cost efficiencies to drive profitability. The firm's focus list includes ICICI Bank and Bajaj Finance.
Global Context and Market Positioning
Comparing India with China, Garner noted that China's nominal GDP growth remains weak and lacks clear catalysts for broad cyclical recovery. On commodities, Morgan Stanley remains constructive on gold, driven by rising demand for real assets amid high global debt levels.
While Morgan Stanley has reduced risk exposure after four years of Indian market outperformance, India remains one of the firm's preferred markets for the year ahead, alongside Brazil, the UAE and Singapore. "The key question is whether this cyclical downturn in India—which surprised us in its intensity—now abates and improves. If it does, India should once again stand out within the Asia and emerging market universe," Garner concluded.
Historical Stock Returns for Nippon Life India AMC
| 1 Day | 5 Days | 1 Month | 6 Months | 1 Year | 5 Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| -0.14% | +0.26% | +1.57% | +1.35% | +28.51% | +163.07% |




























