USDA report reveals $10.1B in SNAP payment errors
A USDA report for fiscal 2025 shows a 10.62% SNAP error rate, leading to $10.1 billion in improper payments. States with high error rates face financial penalties starting October 2027, potentially triggering budget cuts or program exits.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture on Wednesday released fiscal 2025 payment error rates for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), revealing a national error rate of 10.62% and $10.1 billion in improper payments nationwide. This figure significantly exceeds the federal threshold of 6%, placing multiple states at risk of financial penalties under a new cost-sharing law set to take effect in October 2027.
SNAP provides monthly food assistance to low-income households. Payment errors, defined as benefits paid above or below the correct amount, are largely attributed to administrative mistakes rather than fraud. The new regulations will require states with error rates of 6% or higher to cover a portion of benefit costs, with penalties scaling up based on the severity of the error rate.
Financial Penalties for States
Under the new law, states with error rates between 6% and 8% must pay 5% of benefit costs. Those with rates between 8% and 10% are liable for 10%, while states exceeding 10% face a 15% cost-sharing requirement. Nine states, including South Dakota and Nebraska, posted error rates below 6% and will avoid these penalties.
| Error Rate Range | State Cost Share |
|---|---|
| Below 6% | 0% |
| 6% – 8% | 5% |
| 8% – 10% | 10% |
| Above 10% | 15% |
Missouri, which recorded an 8.7% error rate, could face approximately $150 million in annual SNAP costs if benefit levels remain unchanged. "These payment error rates are further proof that state accountability is severely lacking in SNAP," said Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins.
State Responses and System Upgrades
States are investing millions to upgrade eligibility systems to comply with the new rules. Contractors such as Deloitte, Accenture PLC, and Optum are assisting states in updating SNAP and Medicaid systems to track work requirements, exemptions, and documentation. These upgrades come as SNAP enrollment has fallen from 42.8 million recipients in January 2025 to 38.6 million by January 2026, partly due to stricter work requirements and eligibility thresholds.
Some states may respond by tightening eligibility further or cutting spending in other areas like education or mental health programs. A survey by the American Public Human Services Association indicated that more than a quarter of states might narrow eligibility policies, while four are considering withdrawing from SNAP entirely. "There are billions of dollars that are at stake that states will have to find the money to be able to pay if they want to continue to operate a SNAP program," said Chloe Green, assistant director for policy at the association.
How will the potential withdrawal of four states from SNAP impact the national food assistance infrastructure and recipient access?
What is the projected return on investment for states spending millions on system upgrades versus the cost of impending federal penalties?
Will the stricter eligibility policies adopted to lower error rates lead to a significant increase in food insecurity among eligible households?






























