Bombay High Court Modifies Order on Kirloskar Trademark Usage
The Bombay High Court has modified its earlier order regarding Kirloskar trademarks, further restricting Kirloskar Proprietary Limited's (KPL) ability to license and assign these marks. KPL is now restrained from licensing and assigning Kirloskar marks to other group companies for businesses competing or overlapping with Kirloskar Brothers Limited (KBL). While KPL can still create licenses for its member companies, it cannot extend this right to other Kirloskar group companies competing with KBL. The financial implications of this litigation are currently undetermined for KBL.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
The Bombay High Court has issued a significant modification to its earlier order regarding the use of Kirloskar trademarks, impacting the dynamics within the Kirloskar group of companies. This development comes as part of an ongoing legal dispute involving Kirloskar Brothers Limited (KBL) and Kirloskar Proprietary Limited (KPL).
Key Points of the Modified Order
- Original Order Date: July 25
- Petitioner: Kirloskar Brothers Limited
Details of the Modification
The court has now expanded its restrictions on KPL's ability to use the Kirloskar trademarks. The key changes are as follows:
Aspect | Previous Order | Modified Order |
---|---|---|
Licensing | Allowed | Restricted |
Assignment | Restricted | Restricted |
Scope | Similar/overlapping businesses | Competing/overlapping businesses |
Implications of the Order
Restricted Trademark Usage: KPL is now restrained from both licensing and assigning Kirloskar marks to other group companies for businesses that compete or overlap with Kirloskar Brothers Limited.
Limited Licensing Rights: While KPL can still create licenses for Kirloskar marks in favor of its member companies as per its articles of association, it cannot extend this right to other Kirloskar group companies that might compete with KBL.
Financial Impact: Kirloskar Brothers Limited has stated that the expected financial implications of this litigation cannot be determined at this time.
Background of the Dispute
This modification is part of an ongoing legal battle within the Kirloskar group. The dispute traces back to earlier court proceedings, including:
- An order by the Pune Court on January 9
- The Bombay High Court's initial ad-interim order on July 25
- Previous disclosures by Kirloskar Brothers Limited on July 4, 2018, January 21, and August 12
Conclusion
This latest court order represents a significant development in the trademark dispute within the Kirloskar group. It underscores the complexities involved in managing intellectual property rights within large business conglomerates, especially when different group companies have overlapping or competing interests. The full impact of this decision on the operations and relationships within the Kirloskar group remains to be seen, and further developments in this ongoing legal matter are likely to be closely watched by stakeholders and industry observers alike.
Historical Stock Returns for Kirloskar Brothers
1 Day | 5 Days | 1 Month | 6 Months | 1 Year | 5 Years |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
+0.79% | +0.03% | -0.79% | +19.25% | +14.57% | +1,660.27% |