Investors call for Disney breakup as stock trails S&P 500
Ross Gerber renewed calls for The Walt Disney Co. to break up or sell, citing underperformance versus the S&P 500 for 11 years and suggesting Apple Inc. as a potential acquirer. Wells Fargo analyst Steven Cahall maintained an Overweight rating, suggesting a 40% upside if Disney exits streaming to focus on licensing, which could generate over $15 billion annually. The stock has fallen over 45% in five years.
*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Investor Ross Gerber renewed his call for a major shake-up at The Walt Disney Co., stating shareholders have "suffered too long" as the stock significantly lagged the S&P 500 over the past 11 years. Gerber, CEO of Gerber Kawasaki, argued that Disney's individual businesses are worth more separately than together and urged the company to "break up the mouse house or sell it." This intervention follows a post by Creative Planning's Charlie Bilello highlighting that Disney lost 10.93% over the past 11 years while the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust gained 320.1%.
Gerber Advocates for Apple Acquisition or Split
Gerber has repeatedly criticized Disney's strategy in recent days, suggesting Apple Inc. should either acquire Disney to become "the ultimate consumer company" or exit the entertainment business altogether. He asserted that Disney management had failed to unlock the value of its assets and argued shareholders were "sick of the dawdling" while executives continued to receive large compensation packages. Over the past five years, Disney has lost more than 45% of its market value. The stock is down 20.58% over the past year and has fallen 14.05% so far this year.
Wells Fargo Suggests Streaming Exit
Separately, Wells Fargo analyst Steven Cahall proposed that Disney return to its historical model of producing content rather than distributing it directly through Disney+. The bank maintained its Overweight rating on Disney despite lowering its price target to $125 from $146, while UBS analyst John Hodulik maintained a Buy rating but lowered the price target to $133 from $138. Cahall estimated the shift could add about 40% to Disney’s stock price by reducing earnings risk and allowing management to focus on its intellectual property and experiences business.
Licensing Revenue Potential
Wells Fargo estimated Disney could earn nearly $4 billion annually from global pay-one licensing rights alone after comparing Disney’s box office performance with Sony Group Corp’s movie licensing agreement. The analyst noted that Disney commands 3 times the global box office, implying nearly $4 billion for global pay-one licensing alone. Cahall estimated that including pay-two licensing windows and Disney’s content library could lift annual licensing revenue above $15 billion, providing a far more reliable cash engine than the company’s direct-to-consumer streaming business.
| Metric | Performance |
|---|---|
| 11-Year Return | -10.93% |
| S&P 500 11-Year Return | 320.1% |
| 5-Year Market Value Change | -45% |
| 1-Year Stock Change | -20.58% |
| YTD Stock Change | -14.05% |
Disney closed 0.21% lower on Tuesday at $96.14 and edged 0.07% higher in extended trading.
How might Apple's potential acquisition of Disney reshape the competitive landscape of the media and tech industries?
What are the risks and rewards for Disney if it pivots back to a licensing-heavy model instead of direct-to-consumer streaming?
Could Disney's underperformance trigger broader shareholder activism or leadership changes in the near term?
16
Create Custom Screeners 
Access 200+ Pre-built Filters 
Use 50+ Readymade Screener 
