Icahn criticizes BlackRock for protecting bad CEOs
Carl Icahn publicly criticized BlackRock and Larry Fink for supporting entrenched management over shareholders, citing a $9 billion loss at Motorola Solutions. He detailed his activist campaign at Motorola, which led to a corporate split and a $12.5 billion Google acquisition. Motorola Solutions recently announced a $1.5 billion acquisition of D-Fend Solutions.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
During the July 2015 CNBC Institutional Investor Delivering Alpha Conference, activist investor Carl Icahn criticized BlackRock CEO Larry Fink for backing corporate management over activist shareholders. Icahn argued that Fink’s annual letters to CEOs served as a sales pitch for BlackRock, encouraging debt issuance and acquisitions under the guise of long-term planning. He stated this approach increased BlackRock's assets under management while shielding underperforming executives from accountability.
Icahn used Motorola Solutions as a primary example, noting the company lost $9 billion in value before activists intervened. He claimed BlackRock refused to support his campaign to overhaul the company, despite his eventual success in improving its performance. "We saved the company. Wouldn't vote for me," Icahn said regarding BlackRock's stance.
Icahn's Campaign at Motorola
Motorola’s struggles stemmed from its inability to replicate the success of its RAZR handset. Sales of follow-up models like the KRZR missed expectations as competitors Nokia and Samsung gained market share, and Apple's iPhone reshaped the industry. The handset division slipped into losses, triggering Icahn’s activist campaign in 2007.
Icahn initially sought a $12 billion share buyback before escalating to a proxy fight for board seats. After failing to win representation, he intensified pressure through public letters, a lawsuit for company records, and criticism of leadership, eventually raising his stake to over 10%. The company agreed to appoint two of his nominees and split into Motorola Mobility and Motorola Solutions in 2011.
| Event | Detail |
|---|---|
| Initial Demand | $12 billion share buyback |
| Stake Acquired | More than 10% |
| Outcome | Split into Motorola Mobility and Motorola Solutions |
| Google Acquisition | $12.5 billion for Motorola Mobility |
BlackRock's Influence and Motorola's Future
Icahn argued that BlackRock’s management of about $4.8 trillion allowed it to protect entrenched management teams instead of supporting shareholder-driven reforms. While stating he respected Fink personally, Icahn called BlackRock's voting practices "very dangerous" for U.S. capital markets because they discouraged accountability.
BlackRock was a major institutional shareholder in Motorola during Icahn’s 2007–2008 campaign and supported the incumbent board against his proposed reforms. Following the 2011 split, BlackRock continued to hold investments in the successor companies. In June, Motorola Solutions announced its $1.5 billion acquisition of D-Fend Solutions to expand airspace security capabilities. The deal is expected to close in the fourth quarter of 2026.
Will BlackRock adjust its voting policies on proxy fights in response to increasing criticism from activists like Carl Icahn?
How will the recent $1.5 billion acquisition of D-Fend Solutions impact Motorola Solutions' long-term growth strategy following its historic split?
Could the ideological conflict between passive index managers and activist shareholders lead to increased regulatory scrutiny of proxy voting practices?

































