TCIL Blacklists Cisco for Two Years Over Alleged Unfair Practices in Karnataka Tender
TCIL has blacklisted Cisco for two years following allegations of unfair practices in the Karnataka KSWAN project tender. The PSU claims Cisco manipulated the bidding process through last-minute conditions and artificial hurdles. The controversy involves tender CEG/2025-26/IND0043, which was cancelled and re-issued, raising concerns about creating monopolistic conditions in government procurement.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Public sector telecommunications consultant TCIL has imposed a two-year blacklist on global technology major Cisco, effectively barring the company from participating in any future tenders floated by the PSU. The decisive action follows serious allegations of unfair business practices that allegedly compromised the integrity of a government bidding process.
Allegations Against Cisco
TCIL has accused Cisco of engaging in unfair, illegal and monopolistic practices that adversely impacted a recent government bidding process. According to the PSU, Cisco deliberately sabotaged its bid for a tender floated by the Karnataka government by introducing last-minute conditions and creating artificial hurdles designed to undermine TCIL's participation.
The allegations suggest these actions were strategically aimed at securing unlawful commercial gains for Cisco, raising serious concerns about fair competition in government procurement processes.
Karnataka KSWAN Project Controversy
The dispute centers around tender reference CEG/2025-26/IND0043 and its subsequent re-issue, which has drawn criticism over alleged manipulation of the bidding process. The controversy relates to the Karnataka State Wide Area Network (KSWAN) project, a critical initiative designed to provide secure and reliable network connectivity across government offices throughout the state.
| Project Details: | Information |
|---|---|
| Project Name: | Karnataka State Wide Area Network (KSWAN) |
| Tender Reference: | CEG/2025-26/IND0043 |
| Preparatory Work Started: | 2022 |
| Original Tender Date: | July 11, 2025 |
| Revised Tender Date: | December 8, 2025 |
Bidding Process Timeline
The Centre for e-Governance (CeG) initially framed the Request for Proposal (RFP) to support a multi-OEM architecture and conventional routing-based network design, aligning with established industry standards. The original tender floated on July 11, 2025, attracted significant interest from major players in the telecommunications sector.
| Bidding Participants: | Role |
|---|---|
| RailTel: | Bidder |
| Orange: | Bidder |
| TCIL: | Bidder |
| Cisco: | OEM Partner |
| Juniper: | OEM Partner |
Tender Cancellation and Re-issue
Despite receiving three competitive bids, authorities reportedly opened only the pre-qualification documents before cancelling the entire tender, citing 'improper' submissions. This decision raised eyebrows within the industry, particularly given the participation of established telecommunications companies.
Following the cancellation, CeG constituted a technical committee that claimed the earlier specifications were 'outdated'. The committee's recommendations led to the issuance of a revised tender on December 8, 2025. Critics have alleged that this process created a de facto single-vendor scenario, potentially undermining the competitive bidding process that government procurement rules are designed to ensure.
Industry Impact
The blacklisting of a major technology provider like Cisco by a public sector entity represents a significant development in India's telecommunications procurement landscape. The two-year ban will prevent Cisco from participating in TCIL tenders during this period, potentially affecting the company's business prospects in the public sector telecommunications segment. The controversy also highlights ongoing challenges in ensuring fair and transparent bidding processes in government technology procurement.
Historical Stock Returns for PTC Industries
| 1 Day | 5 Days | 1 Month | 6 Months | 1 Year | 5 Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| -0.54% | +1.90% | -1.46% | +24.03% | +3.86% | +485.25% |
















































