HDFC Bank top pick, ICICI Bank next best: BNP Paribas
BNP Paribas analyst Santanu Chakrabarti maintains HDFC Bank as his top banking sector pick, citing margin expansion and improving liability structure post-merger. ICICI Bank ranks as his second choice due to strong track record and leadership continuity, though he notes near-term risks from weaker retail loan growth. Despite recent PSU bank rallies, he remains neutral on State Bank of India, expressing concerns over sustainability of returns driven by high leverage and unusually low credit costs.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Santanu Chakrabarti, India Analyst – BFSI at BNP Paribas, remains constructive on large private banks, positioning HDFC Bank as his top pick and ICICI Bank as a close second. However, he maintains a more cautious stance on PSU banks despite their recent rally.
HDFC Bank: Top Investment Choice
HDFC Bank remains Chakrabarti's number one idea in the banking space, supported by several key factors:
| Parameter | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Topline Growth | Largely in line with expectations |
| Margin Expansion | Quarter-on-quarter improvement |
| Liability Structure | Gradually improving post-merger |
| Long-term Outlook | Re-rating story remains intact |
Chakrabarti noted that while HDFC Bank is still dealing with a less-than-optimal liability structure following the merger, this situation is gradually improving. As high-cost liabilities roll off over time, margins should benefit from a steady and benign tailwind. Even if margins soften in the near term across the sector, he believes the bank's longer-term re-rating story remains firmly in place.
The analyst expects the market to focus more on margins and loan growth trends rather than short-term movements in credit costs, which supports his positive outlook on the bank.
ICICI Bank: Strong Second Choice
ICICI Bank continues to be a preferred name in Chakrabarti's coverage, backed by its strong track record over the last four to five years and continuity in leadership. He believes this stability should support the bank's performance over the next 12 months.
However, he identified a near-term risk that could create opportunities:
- Slight weakness in retail loan growth over recent quarters
- Reduced savings account accretion in the last couple of quarters
- Very high market expectations that could lead to stock pressure
Chakrabarti views any potential weakness as a buying opportunity for long-term investors, given the bank's fundamentally strong position.
Cautious Stance on PSU Banks
Despite acknowledging the strong recent performance of PSU banks, Chakrabarti maintains a neutral view on State Bank of India, citing concerns around sustainability of returns.
| Risk Factor | Impact |
|---|---|
| High Leverage Dependency | Mid-teen ROE relies on unsustainable factors |
| Unusually Low Credit Costs | Unlikely to be sustainable long-term |
| Normalization Risk | Could sharply hurt earnings growth |
| Return Ratios | Limited further upside potential |
He explained that PSU banks rely heavily on high leverage and unusually low credit costs to deliver mid-teen returns on equity. Such low credit costs are unlikely to be sustainable, and even a normalization to moderate levels could sharply hurt earnings growth and return ratios, limiting further upside despite healthy balance sheets and market share gains.
Investment Strategy Focus
Chakrabarti's analysis suggests a clear preference for large private banks over PSU banks, emphasizing the importance of sustainable business models and long-term structural improvements. His approach focuses on banks with strong fundamentals, leadership stability, and clear paths to margin expansion rather than those dependent on potentially unsustainable cost advantages.
Historical Stock Returns for HDFC Bank
| 1 Day | 5 Days | 1 Month | 6 Months | 1 Year | 5 Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| -0.34% | -1.18% | -6.68% | -7.04% | +12.33% | +25.13% |
















































