Carney Proposes Coalition Strategy for Middle Powers as Trump Asserts US Dominance at Davos
Canadian PM Mark Carney presented a strategic framework at Davos for middle powers to form coalitions and reduce US dependence, contrasting with Trump's assertive approach emphasizing American leverage over allies. Carney's two-stage program involves accepting the end of the liberal world order and building new alliances among lesser powers to navigate between major global competitors.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney outlined a comprehensive strategy for middle powers to navigate an increasingly assertive US foreign policy approach, presenting his framework at the World Economic Forum in Davos. His proposal comes as a direct response to what he characterizes as the end of the traditional Western alliance structure.
Carney's Two-Stage Recovery Program
Carney's strategy for American allies consists of two distinct phases designed to help nations adapt to changing global dynamics. The first stage requires accepting that the liberal world order has permanently ended, with no benefit in invoking or longing for previous arrangements. He emphasized that great powers will pursue their perceived interests regardless of traditional partnerships.
The second stage involves forming coalitions among nations that have been marginalized by major powers. Carney described his efforts to build various connections and alliances with other lesser powers, aimed at reducing each nation's vulnerabilities in their specific areas of interest or exposure.
Trump's Response and Assertions
Trump's address at the same forum demonstrated a markedly different approach to international relations. The US President emphasized American leverage over European allies, stating that Europe would "not exist" without US support. His remarks covered multiple areas he considers national security priorities, including pharmaceutical prices, trade deficits, and territorial interests.
Trump directly addressed Carney's proposals, warning: "Canada lives because of the United States. Remember that, Mark, next time you're going to make one of your statements." This response came after Trump had outlined his approach to negotiations with European leaders, describing previous instances where he had successfully pressured allies into accepting higher tariffs and drug prices.
Strategic Diversification Efforts
Carney detailed Canada's specific efforts to strengthen its position through diversification initiatives. Since taking office, he has worked to diversify and solidify Canada's markets, supplies, and security relationships. These efforts represent a practical response to what he describes as threats regarding Canada potentially becoming the 51st US state.
| Strategic Focus Areas: | Implementation Approach |
|---|---|
| Market Diversification: | Expanding trade relationships beyond US dependence |
| Supply Chain Security: | Strengthening alternative supplier networks |
| Security Partnerships: | Building relationships with multiple defense partners |
| Economic Resilience: | Reducing reliance on American financial systems |
Implications for Global Alliances
The contrasting approaches presented at Davos highlight fundamental changes in international relations. Carney's framework acknowledges the reality of navigating between major powers including Vladimir Putin's Russia, Xi Jinping's China, and Trump's United States. His approach emphasizes pragmatism, suggesting allies must stand up to pressure when possible while bending when necessary.
The Canadian leader's strategy requires collective action to recreate rules and conventions that previously brought decades of peace and prosperity, but without American power to enforce them. This transition period presents significant challenges for traditional allies from London to Berlin, and from Tokyo to Sydney.
Long-term Strategic Considerations
Carney's assessment suggests that successful navigation of current global dynamics requires acknowledging weaknesses while simultaneously building military and economic strength. His framework calls for diversifying trade, energy, and security relationships to end overdependence on American resources and protection.
The approach recognizes that while the US gained significant benefits from alliance relationships over eight decades—including market access, investment opportunities, arms sales, and military support—the changing dynamics require new strategic thinking. Carney's proposed diversification and reorientation among middle powers represents a fundamental shift in how smaller nations might organize themselves in response to great power competition.



























