Motilal Oswal Favors Gold Over Silver as Risk-Reward Equation Shifts After Sharp Rally
Motilal Oswal Financial Services favors gold over silver in the near term following silver's 200% rally that compressed the gold-silver ratio to 50. Global silver ETF outflows exceeded 3 million ounces since 2026 start while gold ETFs see steady inflows. Rising macro uncertainty and geopolitical tensions support rotation toward safer havens, though the brokerage maintains positive long-term silver outlook.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Motilal Oswal Financial Services believes gold is relatively better positioned than silver in the current market environment, as the sharp rally in silver has altered the near-term risk-reward equation for precious metals amid rising macro uncertainty.
Silver Rally Compresses Gold-Silver Ratio
In a January 21 commodities note, Motilal Oswal highlighted silver's exceptional performance over the past 12 months. The precious metal has delivered a rally of over 200%, significantly outperforming gold's roughly 80% rise during the same period.
| Metric: | Performance |
|---|---|
| Silver Rally: | Over 200% (past 12 months) |
| Gold Rally: | Roughly 80% (past 12 months) |
| Gold-Silver Ratio (Current): | Around 50 |
| Gold-Silver Ratio (Pandemic High): | Near 127 |
The brokerage noted that this outperformance has compressed the gold-silver ratio to around 50 at the start of 2026 from pandemic highs near 127, signaling that a large part of silver's catch-up trade has already played out.
Investor Flows Show Rotation Pattern
The shift in precious metals dynamics is becoming evident in investor flows. Motilal Oswal observed that global silver ETFs have experienced outflows of more than 3 million ounces since the start of 2026, even as silver prices remain elevated. In contrast, global gold ETFs have continued to see steadier inflows, reflecting a gradual rotation away from higher-beta exposure toward safer havens.
Macro Uncertainty Drives Safe Haven Demand
The brokerage linked the change in investor preference to rising macro and geopolitical uncertainty. Key factors contributing to market unease include:
- Tensions involving the US, Iran and Venezuela
- Risks in the Middle East
- Delayed impact of tariffs
- Concerns around a potential US government shutdown
Motilal Oswal also pointed to expanding global liquidity as a key driver supporting precious metals, noting that US M2 money supply stands near $22.00 trillion and China's M2 has crossed about ¥340.00 trillion, growing at over 8% year-on-year.
Physical Market Dynamics and Valuation Concerns
While maintaining a positive view on silver's longer-term structural outlook supported by industrial demand and supply constraints, Motilal Oswal noted that the near-term setup looks more imbalanced after the rally. The brokerage flagged tightness in physical silver markets but warned that premiums may reflect stretched pricing.
| Market: | Premium Details |
|---|---|
| Shanghai Silver: | $10.00-11.00 per ounce above COMEX |
| MCX Silver: | Over 10% premium |
| Indian Silver Price Movement: | From ₹60,000.00 to ₹3.20 lakh |
On relative valuation, the brokerage noted that the gold-silver ratio typically averages near 70 over the long term and is currently near 50, a level it considers difficult to sustain. A move back toward 65-70 would imply relative outperformance of gold, supporting a tilt toward gold as a volatility-managed allocation strategy.
Strategic Positioning Recommendations
Motilal Oswal emphasized that it is not changing its overall stance on precious metals but expects near-term allocations to skew more toward gold while silver remains a long-term core holding. The brokerage noted that silver's rise increases the probability of portfolio rebalancing by larger investors at current levels, while gold continues to trade in a more stable trend, improving its appeal for risk-managed positioning.

































