65% of Nifty 500 stocks trade in overvalued zone, Omniscience Capital study reveals
An Omniscience Capital study shows 65% of Nifty 500 stocks are overvalued. The Nifty 500 index trades at a 24.40 P/E ratio with 11% growth estimates. Large-caps trade at 22.80x P/E, mid-caps at 28.10x, and small-caps at 29.50x with 11.7% growth expectations. Financials emerge as the most attractively positioned sector, while consumer staples, healthcare, and IT appear overvalued. The study suggests investors should be selective, focusing on the 35% of fairly valued or undervalued stocks.
*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
A recent study by investment management firm Omniscience Capital has revealed that a significant majority of India's top stocks are currently trading in overvalued territory. The comprehensive analysis of Nifty 500 constituents shows that nearly 65% of these stocks appear overvalued, while the remaining 35% are trading at fair or undervalued levels.
Current Market Valuation Metrics
The Nifty 500 index is presently valued at 24.40 times price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, with growth estimates of approximately 11%. According to the report, the current valuation multiple appears elevated when measured against expected earnings growth prospects.
| Market Segment | P/E Multiple | Growth Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Nifty 500 Index | 24.40x | ~11% |
| Large-cap (Top 100) | 22.80x | - |
| Mid-cap (101-250) | 28.10x | - |
| Small-cap | 29.50x | ~11.7% |
Market Capitalisation Analysis
The study reveals significant valuation disparities across different market capitalisation segments:
- Large-cap stocks, comprising the top 100 companies, are trading at a relatively moderate P/E multiple of 22.80 times.
- Mid-cap stocks, ranked between 101 to 250, command higher valuations at 28.10 times P/E.
- Small-cap stocks present the most concerning valuation scenario, trading at 29.50 times price-to-earnings while expected to deliver earnings growth of approximately 11.7%.
The report specifically notes that small-cap stocks appear overvalued relative to their fundamental prospects.
Sector-wise Positioning
The sectoral analysis provides a mixed picture of investment opportunities across different industry segments. According to the study, the financial sector emerges as the most attractively positioned sector in the current market environment.
| Sector Category | Valuation Assessment |
|---|---|
| Financials | Most attractively positioned |
| Utilities | Favourable prospects |
| Industrials | Favourable prospects |
| Energy | Favourable prospects |
| Consumer Staples | Overvalued vs. growth |
| Health Care | Overvalued vs. growth |
| Information Technology | Overvalued vs. growth |
Several sectors show favourable investment prospects, including utilities, industrials, and energy. However, consumer staples, healthcare, and information technology sectors demonstrate overvaluation when compared to their expected growth trajectories.
Market Implications
The findings highlight the current challenging environment for equity investors, with a substantial portion of India's leading stocks trading above their intrinsic values. The study suggests that investors need to be increasingly selective in their stock picking approach, focusing on the 35% of stocks that remain fairly valued or undervalued. The pronounced overvaluation in small-cap segments particularly warrants caution, given the significant premium these stocks command relative to their growth potential.
18
