Nasscom Warns Against H-1B Wage-Weighted System, Cites Talent Pipeline Risks

4 min read     Updated on 24 Dec 2025, 08:03 PM
scanx
Reviewed by
Anirudha BScanX News Team
Overview

India's tech industry body Nasscom has raised comprehensive concerns about the Trump administration's proposed shift to a wage-weighted H-1B visa selection system, warning it could disadvantage small firms, startups, and research institutions while disrupting the critical talent pipeline for US-educated STEM graduates. The organization calls for phased implementation with adequate lead time, as a federal court simultaneously upholds the administration's decision to increase H-1B application fees to $100,000, creating additional challenges for Indian IT companies and professionals.

28132423

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.

The Trump administration is implementing a comprehensive overhaul of the H-1B visa program, replacing the decades-old random lottery system with a merit-based selection process that prioritizes higher-skilled and higher-paid foreign workers. The US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) announced these sweeping changes on December 23, with implementation scheduled for February 27, 2026, affecting the FY 2027 H-1B cap registration season.

Nasscom Raises Comprehensive Concerns

National Association of Software and Service Companies (Nasscom), India's technology industry body, has issued a detailed statement warning of significant risks from the proposed wage-weighted H-1B visa selection system. The organization cautioned that while the intent to promote high-skill employment and protect US wages is understandable, the reform could create substantial legal, economic, and operational challenges.

Nasscom Key Concerns Impact Details
System Focus Shift From "specialty occupation" to wage ranking
Regional Distortions Geography-based wage variations create bias
SME Disadvantage Small firms and startups face selection challenges
Talent Pipeline Risk Entry-level STEM graduates affected
Implementation Timeline Sudden transition increases compliance complexity

Nasscom emphasized that assigning multiple selection entries based on wage levels risks shifting the statutory focus away from "specialty occupation" towards wage ranking, potentially leading to regional and occupational distortions. The organization noted that wage levels vary widely by geography and role, which could disadvantage employers operating with moderate but market-appropriate wage structures.

Impact on Different Employer Categories

The proposed wage-weighted system creates distinct challenges for various types of employers in the US technology ecosystem. Nasscom specifically highlighted concerns about how the new system would affect different organizational structures and their ability to secure H-1B talent.

Affected Employer Types Specific Challenges
Small and Mid-sized Firms Limited ability to offer top-tier wages
Startups Moderate wage structures vs. selection probability
Research Institutions Academic salary scales disadvantaged
University-linked Employers Educational sector wage constraints
Large Corporations Increased competition for high-wage positions

The industry body warned that Level I and Level II wage bands, which often represent entry-level roles for US-educated STEM graduates, form a critical talent pipeline. Restricting these opportunities could weaken future innovation and discourage international students from pursuing advanced education in the US.

Court Upholds Fee Increases

Simultaneously, a US federal judge has ruled that the Trump administration can proceed with its decision to increase H-1B visa application fees to $100,000. US District Judge Beryl Howell rejected arguments from the US Chamber of Commerce, determining that Trump's proclamation was issued under "an express statutory grant of authority to the President."

Legal Development Details
Judge US District Judge Beryl Howell
Date December 23
Fee Amount $100,000 per application
Legal Basis Express statutory grant of authority
Challenger US Chamber of Commerce

The judge acknowledged the move could "inflict significant harm on American businesses and institutions of higher education," but found that Congress had provided sufficient authority for the administration's actions. At least two additional lawsuits against the H-1B visa application fee remain ongoing.

Nasscom's Implementation Recommendations

Recognizing the complexity of the proposed changes, Nasscom has called for a more measured approach to implementation. The organization stressed that a sudden transition would increase compliance complexity and disrupt established workforce planning processes across the technology sector.

Nasscom Recommendations Implementation Strategy
Phased Implementation Gradual transition with adequate lead time
Timeline Adjustment Deferred to later lottery cycle
Stakeholder Consultation Enhanced industry engagement
Framework Preservation Maintain transparent and trusted visa system
Confidence Maintenance Protect US talent and investment environment

If a wage-weighted model is pursued, Nasscom emphasized that a phased implementation with adequate lead time, potentially deferred to a later lottery cycle, would be essential to maintain confidence in the US talent and investment environment. The organization urged policymakers to preserve a transparent and trusted visa framework to sustain the strength of the US technology ecosystem.

Broader Implications for Indian IT Sector

These developments significantly impact Indian IT companies and professionals, who have historically been major beneficiaries of the H-1B program. The combination of substantially higher fees and the shift from lottery-based to merit-based selection requires companies to reconfigure their hiring strategies and business models.

Indian IT firms must now adapt to a system that prioritizes higher-skilled positions and increased compensation levels, representing a fundamental departure from the random selection process. The changes align with the Trump administration's broader immigration policies and stated goal of preventing the replacement of American workers with lower-paid foreign alternatives.

like16
dislike

US Proposes Significant Changes to H-1B Visa Program, Impacting Indian IT Professionals

1 min read     Updated on 10 Oct 2025, 11:20 AM
scanx
Reviewed by
Shraddha JScanX News Team
Overview

The US Department of Homeland Security has proposed significant modifications to the H-1B visa program. Key changes include revising cap exemptions, increasing scrutiny for employers with past violations, enhancing oversight of third-party placements, and imposing a $100,000 mandatory fee on new applications. The administration is also considering replacing the lottery system with a wage-based selection process. These changes could significantly impact Indian students and professionals, especially those in IT services and consulting sectors. New rules could be issued as early as December, potentially reshaping the landscape for H-1B visa applicants.

21621055

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.

The United States Department of Homeland Security has proposed substantial modifications to the H-1B visa program, potentially affecting thousands of Indian students and professionals seeking employment in the US. These changes aim to enhance program integrity and protect American workers' wages and working conditions.

Key Proposed Changes

  1. Revision of Cap Exemptions: The proposal includes changes to eligibility criteria for cap exemptions, which could impact non-profit research organizations, universities, and healthcare institutions that currently benefit from these exemptions.

  2. Increased Scrutiny: Employers who have previously violated program requirements will face heightened scrutiny.

  3. Enhanced Oversight: The proposal includes measures to improve oversight of third-party placements.

  4. New Application Fee: A $100,000 mandatory fee has been imposed on new H-1B visa applications, primarily affecting Indian workers in IT services and consulting sectors.

  5. Potential Wage-Based Selection: The administration is considering replacing the traditional H-1B lottery system with a wage-based selection process.

Timeline and Impact

The Department of Homeland Security suggests that new rules could be issued as early as December. These changes have the potential to significantly impact the landscape for H-1B visa applicants, particularly those from India working in the IT and consulting industries.

Implications for Indian Professionals

The proposed changes could have far-reaching consequences for Indian students and professionals aspiring to work in the United States. The IT services and consulting sectors, which have traditionally relied heavily on the H-1B program, may face particular challenges under the new rules.

Aspect Current System Proposed Changes
Application Process Lottery-based selection Potential wage-based selection
Application Fee Standard fees Additional $100,000 mandatory fee
Eligibility Broader exemptions Revised eligibility for cap exemptions
Employer Requirements Standard oversight Increased scrutiny for violators
Third-Party Placements Less regulated Enhanced oversight

These proposed modifications to the H-1B visa program represent a significant shift in U.S. immigration policy for skilled workers. As the situation develops, potential applicants and current visa holders should stay informed about these changes and their potential impacts on employment opportunities in the United States.

like18
dislike
Explore Other Articles