Trump's Welfare Data Chart Excludes India as Indian Immigrants Show Low Public Assistance Usage
Trump's Truth Social welfare data chart covering 120 countries excluded India, likely due to a 25% assistance threshold, while showing high usage rates for other South Asian nations like Bangladesh (54.8%) and Pakistan (40.2%). Research indicates Indian immigrants, numbering 5.2 million in 2023, earn among the highest incomes of any ethnic group with minimal public assistance reliance. The Manhattan Institute study identifies them as the most economically beneficial immigrant group, with each Indian immigrant saving the federal government $1.7 million over 30 years.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Trump released comprehensive welfare data on his Truth Social platform, presenting information on immigrant households from approximately 120 countries and territories receiving government assistance in the United States. The chart detailed the percentage of immigrant households from each country receiving some form of government assistance, though it did not specify the exact type or duration of assistance included in the data.
Notable Exclusions and Inclusions
The chart notably excluded India despite including other South Asian nations with significant welfare usage rates. Bangladesh led South Asian countries with 54.8% of immigrant households receiving assistance, followed by Pakistan at 40.2% and Nepal at 34.8%. The data also included China at 32.9%, Israel/Palestine at 25.9%, Ukraine at 42.7%, and Asia (not elsewhere classified/not specified) at 38.8%.
Top Countries by Welfare Usage
The data revealed the countries with the highest percentage of immigrant households receiving welfare assistance:
| Country: | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Bhutan: | 81.4% |
| Yemen: | 75.2% |
| Somalia: | 71.9% |
| Marshall Islands: | 71.4% |
| Dominican Republic: | 68.1% |
| Afghanistan: | 68.1% |
| Congo: | 66.0% |
| Guinea: | 65.8% |
| Samoa (1940–1950): | 63.4% |
| Cape Verde: | 63.1% |
India's Absence from the Chart
India's exclusion from the chart appears to stem from a cutoff threshold, with the data identifying nations where immigrant aid consumption exceeded approximately 25%. Public research conducted over many years has consistently shown that Indian immigrants in the United States earn among the highest incomes of any ethnic group. They maintain high workforce participation rates and demonstrate minimal reliance on public assistance programs.
Indian Immigrant Demographics and Economic Impact
According to US Census Bureau estimates, approximately 5.2 million people in the United States identified as Indian in 2023. The Pew Research Centre reported in 2025 that Indian Americans represent the second-largest Asian origin population living in the US, accounting for approximately 21% of the country's Asian population.
Indian immigrants play a significant role in the US economy as substantial contributors to income tax revenues. They have been instrumental in founding or co-founding a large share of startups in Silicon Valley, demonstrating their entrepreneurial impact on the American business landscape.
Economic Benefits Analysis
A recent study published by the Manhattan Institute identified Indian immigrants as the most economically beneficial immigrant group in the country. Daniel Di Martino, a fellow at the Manhattan Institute, stated that "The average Indian immigrant and his or her descendants will save the federal government $1.7 million over 30 years." This research underscores the substantial positive fiscal impact of Indian immigration to the United States.



























