Julius Baer's Mark Matthews: China's 'Manufactured' Bull Run and India's FII Selling Pressure
Julius Baer's Head of Research Asia, Mark Matthews, contrasts China's government-driven stock market growth with India's temporary underperformance. China's 'manufactured bull market' is fueled by low interest rates and efforts to redirect $23 trillion in household savings to equities. India's market pressure stems from foreign investors selling to reallocate to China. Matthews sees potential for parallel growth in both markets, anticipates US dollar weakening against emerging currencies, and notes a shift towards a 'G2' global economic structure led by the US and China.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Julius Baer's Head of Research Asia, Mark Matthews, has provided insights into the contrasting market dynamics of China and India, two of Asia's largest economies. Matthews' analysis sheds light on the recent stock market developments in both countries and their implications for global investors.
China's 'Manufactured' Bull Market
According to Matthews, China's recent stock market revival is largely a result of government intervention, which he describes as a 'manufactured bull market.' This engineered growth is driven by two main factors:
- Extremely low interest rates
- Government efforts to redirect household savings into equities
Matthews points out that the Chinese government is attempting to channel a significant portion of the country's $23 trillion in household savings from bank accounts into the stock market. This move aims to gradually build consumer confidence, which was damaged during the COVID-19 pandemic.
India's Market Underperformance
In contrast to China's government-driven growth, Matthews attributes India's recent market underperformance to external factors rather than domestic economic weakness. He highlights that foreign institutional investors (FIIs) have been selling Indian equities to reallocate funds to China, causing temporary pressure on the Indian market.
Key Observations
Matthews makes several important observations about the current global economic landscape:
| Observation | Details |
|---|---|
| China's Growth Target | The government aims for gradual equity market growth of 10-15% annually |
| Global Economic Structure | The world is moving towards a 'G2' structure led by the US and China |
| China's Bond Issuance | Recent bond issuance at yields matching US Treasuries is seen as a positive signal |
| US Dollar Outlook | Expected to weaken against emerging market currencies |
| Emerging Market Equities | Potential tailwinds due to weakening US dollar |
Parallel Growth Potential
Matthews emphasizes that China's market rise doesn't necessarily come at India's expense. He believes that both markets have the potential to grow in parallel, suggesting that investors should not view the situation as a zero-sum game.
Currency and Emerging Markets
Looking ahead, Matthews anticipates that the US dollar will weaken against emerging market currencies. This trend could provide significant tailwinds for emerging market equities, potentially benefiting both Chinese and Indian markets in the long run.
In conclusion, while China's stock market is experiencing a government-engineered bull run, India's market faces temporary pressure from FII selling. However, both markets remain important players in the evolving global economic landscape, with potential for growth as the world moves towards a 'G2' structure led by the US and China.



























