Nifty Valuations Frozen for a Year but Q3 Earnings Season Could Finally Break the Spell
Nifty50's forward PE multiple has remained stagnant at 20.4x for 12 months following two years of weak profit growth. The Q3 earnings season starting next week represents a critical juncture, with analysts divided between optimistic forecasts of sharp recovery led by banks, telecom, and metals versus warnings of continued softness. While some expect 15% index gains, others predict flat year-on-year EPS growth, making this earnings cycle crucial for determining market direction in an environment where margins for error have virtually disappeared.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
India's benchmark Nifty50 index has been trapped in a valuation deadlock for the past 12 months, but the upcoming Q3 earnings season starting next week could serve as the catalyst that either delivers the rerating bulls have been anticipating or extends the market's period of stagnation. With margins for error virtually eliminated, this earnings cycle carries heightened significance for market direction.
Current Valuation Landscape
The market's valuation metrics paint a picture of prolonged stagnation. Key indicators show the extent of this freeze:
| Metric | Current Status | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Nifty 12-month Forward PE | 20.40x | Virtually unchanged from a year ago |
| Profit Growth Period | Two consecutive years | Lackluster performance |
| Market Performance | Record underperformance | Relative to global peers in 2025 |
For the first time in nearly five years, equity valuations appear favorable relative to short-term interest rates, with the modified earnings yield gap suggesting potential equity upside.
Analyst Optimism for Earnings Recovery
Several major brokerages have expressed confidence in an impending earnings turnaround. CLSA analyst Vikash Kumar Jain noted that after two muted years, Nifty earnings are positioned for a sharp rebound, potentially placing India among the fastest-growing markets globally. The recovery is expected to be anchored by banks, with telecom and metals sectors providing additional momentum.
Morgan Stanley's equity strategist Ridham Desai struck an even more bullish tone, forecasting a sharp turn in earnings growth driven by multiple policy support measures:
- RBI and government reflation efforts through rate cuts
- CRR reduction and bank deregulation
- Liquidity infusion and front-loaded capex
- Nearly ₹1.50 trillion in GST rate cuts
IIFL Securities highlighted specific "coiled springs" in Nifty earnings, identifying IndiGo, Tata Motors, banks, and metals as key contributors that should help the index deliver 15.00% gains.
Contrarian Views and Risk Factors
Not all market participants share this optimistic outlook. Nuvama presented a more cautious perspective, warning that Q3 earnings are likely to remain soft as a continuation of the previous six quarters. Their forecasts include:
| Parameter | Nuvama Forecast | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Top-line Growth | ~8.00% YoY | Eleventh straight quarter of subdued growth |
| Profit Growth | 5.00% | Below consensus expectations |
| Nifty EPS | Flat YoY | Posing downgrade risks to mid-teens consensus |
The brokerage identified several risk factors that could derail the recovery, including slower credit growth, NIM compression, tariff delays, and INR-driven margin pressures.
Market Positioning and Valuation Concerns
CLSA noted that while India's relative valuation to peers now appears more palatable, the setup remains precarious. Equities continue to trade at expensive levels relative to bonds, leaving a thin margin of safety. Without meaningful declines in bond yields, index-level returns are likely to remain capped, making earnings delivery the primary driver rather than multiple expansion.
Axis Securities' Neeraj Chadawar maintained a December 2026 Nifty target of 28,100, valuing the index at 20.00 times December 2027 earnings, though he cautioned about potential short-term volatility.
Sector-Specific Recovery Expectations
The anticipated recovery for FY27 appears to have broader consensus support. CLSA expects revenue momentum to return after a muted FY26, with recovery led by:
- Real estate sector
- Industrial segments
- Consumer discretionary categories
Margins should improve modestly, though returns on equity will remain capped as corporates continue deleveraging rather than pursuing aggressive capital expenditure.
Investment Strategy Implications
Analysts emphasize that 2026 will likely reward stock selection over broad index investments. The correction of prior years' excesses has occurred unevenly, creating wider relative valuation dispersion across stocks and sectors. IIFL Securities warned that while foreign institutional investor selling may abate, competition from cheaper markets like China could limit disproportionate flow advantages for India.
The consensus indicates that opportunities increasingly lie in selective stock picking rather than broad market exposure, as headline market valuations remain elevated and limit upside potential at the index level.





































