Nifty Analysts Hit Targets for Third Straight Year
Nifty stocks have beaten analyst expectations for the third year in a row, a feat not seen in over a decade. Out of 47 Nifty companies tracked by at least 10 analysts, 29 stocks surpassed estimates while 18 fell short. Despite this, the NSE Nifty 50 index rose by only 9.70%, underperforming several global markets. Notable outperformers included Eicher Motors, Shriram Finance, Maruti Suzuki, and Bajaj Finance, while Tata Motors, Trent, TCS, and NTPC were among the underperformers. Experts anticipate improved corporate profit growth in the coming year, supported by policy measures enhancing consumer sentiment.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Nifty stocks demonstrated strong performance against analyst expectations for the third consecutive year, marking the first such streak in over a decade. This achievement comes despite the benchmark index delivering relatively modest returns compared to several global peers.
Analyst Accuracy Reaches Multi-Year High
Data comparing analyst 12-month consensus price targets as of January 1 with market prices as of December 29 reveals a notable trend. Among the 47 Nifty companies tracked by at least 10 analysts, 29 stocks surpassed estimates while 18 fell short of expectations.
| Performance Metric | Results |
|---|---|
| Stocks beating estimates | 29 out of 47 |
| Stocks missing estimates | 18 out of 47 |
| Last three-year streak | 2012-2014 |
| Previous year comparison | 10 beats, 38 misses |
This extends a positive trend that began two years ago, representing a sharp reversal from the previous year when only 10 stocks beat estimates and 38 missed them. The last time analyst hits outnumbered misses for three consecutive years was between 2012 and 2014.
Index Performance Lags Global Peers
Despite the higher hit rate at the individual stock level, index returns remained muted. The NSE Nifty 50 rose approximately 9.70%, significantly lagging gains in several global markets.
| Market Index | Performance |
|---|---|
| NSE Nifty 50 | +9.70% |
| Hong Kong Hang Seng | +27.00% |
| Japan Nikkei | +26.00% |
| China CSI 300 | +18.00% |
| US S&P 500 | +18.00% |
| Dow Jones Industrial Average | +14.00% |
Market participants view the improving analyst hit rate as reflecting a shift in market conditions rather than broad-based price momentum. Rahul Singh, Chief Investment Officer for Equities at Tata Asset Management, noted that the Indian market is transitioning from sideways consolidation into a phase of earnings-led optimism, with Nifty valuations having normalised.
Notable Outperformers
Several stocks emerged as major winners, significantly exceeding analyst expectations:
Eicher Motors delivered strong performance driven by record earnings, robust Royal Enfield sales, favorable GST changes, and rising global demand for its products.
Shriram Finance advanced following Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group's announcement on December 19 to acquire a 20% stake through preferential allotment.
Maruti Suzuki gained on expectations of GST cuts for small cars, improved festive sales, higher exports, and a strategic shift towards SUVs in its product portfolio.
Bajaj Finance rose supported by expectations of GST cuts on consumer durables, which market participants viewed as positive for credit demand.
Significant Underperformers
Several prominent stocks failed to meet analyst expectations:
Tata Motors declined due to weak performance at its Jaguar Land Rover unit, including production disruptions from a cyberattack, weak demand in China and Europe, higher US tariffs, and reduced margin guidance.
Trent fell more than 40% after a 136% rise in the previous year, experiencing its first annual decline in over a decade due to slower revenue growth and weaker demand.
Tata Consultancy Services faced pressure from concerns over global demand outlook, layoffs, restructuring activities, and regulatory risks including the proposed ₹83,00,000 H-1B visa fee.
NTPC declined amid prolonged monsoons, lower air conditioner usage, and subdued industrial production, which collectively reduced power demand.
Market Outlook
Experts anticipate that corporate profit growth will improve in the coming year from the single-digit growth observed in the current year, supported by policy measures that have enhanced consumer sentiment. The improving analyst accuracy suggests a more predictable market environment as India transitions into a new phase of economic growth.



























