NewsStocksIndia's Road Quality Reforms Prioritize Technical Merit Over Cost in Infrastructure ProjectsIndia's Road Quality Reforms Prioritize Technical Merit Over Cost in Infrastructure Projects
India's road transport ministry has eliminated financial bids for consultant selection, focusing solely on technical merit to improve infrastructure quality. The reforms address safety concerns from incidents like the Gambhira Bridge collapse and complement revised Hybrid Annuity Model bidding norms. With ₹3.50 trillion worth of highway projects planned for 2025-26, these quality-first changes aim to serve as a template for broader infrastructure development across multiple sectors.
*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
India's road transport ministry has launched comprehensive reforms to address persistent infrastructure quality issues, shifting from cost-based selection to a quality-first approach for consultant hiring and project execution.
Quality Crisis Drives Reform Initiative
Road Transport Minister Nitin Gadkari identified poor Detailed Project Reports (DPRs) as a key factor behind increasing road accidents. The Gambhira Bridge collapse, which resulted in 22 fatalities, exemplified the consequences of infrastructure neglect and cost-cutting measures. Similar quality failures have affected projects including the Morbi bridge collapse, NH-44 closure in Jammu and Kashmir, and cave-ins on National Highway 66 in Kerala.
The traditional procurement approach, often constrained by selecting the lowest bidder (L1), has compromised quality standards. Even the Quality and Cost Based Selection (QCBS) method, which uses weighted average qualification criteria, has shown limitations in ensuring robust infrastructure development.
Technical Merit Takes Priority
In September, the highways ministry announced that consultancy service contracts will be awarded based solely on technical merit, completely removing the financial bid component. This represents a fundamental shift from the previous QCBS method, where consultants were ranked using combined technical and financial scores.
| Reform Component: | Details |
|---|---|
| Selection Criteria: | Technical merit only |
| Financial Bids: | Completely eliminated |
| Performance Evaluation: | Bi-annual assessment by NHAI |
| Focus Area: | DPR quality improvement |
Under the previous system, firms frequently quoted aggressively low prices to improve their financial scores, resulting in substandard DPRs. The National Highways Authority of India now conducts bi-annual evaluations of consultant performance, emphasizing the importance of maintaining reliable track records.
Comprehensive Bidding Reform
The consultant selection changes complement revised bidding norms for Hybrid Annuity Model contracts introduced in July. The ministry has established higher financial and technical thresholds to address the longstanding issue of developers underbidding by 10-15% on L1 contracts.
Key improvements include:
- Fixed maintenance costs to prevent unrealistic low quotes
- Enhanced security requirements from winning contractors
- Stricter technical qualifications for bidder participation
- Improved model concession agreements for clearer project terms
These measures specifically target inexperienced bidders who previously won contracts by quoting unrealistically low prices for future operating and maintenance costs.
Implementation Challenges and Benefits
The quality-first approach promises significant long-term advantages, including roads that last longer, reduced fuel consumption, lower vehicle damage, and improved supply chain reliability. Enhanced model concession agreements and stricter financial filters should reduce project delays and mid-construction complications.
| Expected Outcomes: | Impact |
|---|---|
| Road Durability: | Extended lifespan |
| Fuel Efficiency: | Reduced consumption |
| Vehicle Maintenance: | Lower damage costs |
| Project Completion: | Fewer delays |
However, short-term trade-offs include potential exclusion of mid-tier consultants and developers with inconsistent track records or limited financial capacity. Bidder participation may decrease initially, and bid prices could rise moderately during the transition period.
Strategic Infrastructure Vision
With 124 highway projects worth ₹3.50 trillion planned for 2025-26, India cannot afford to continue building infrastructure requiring constant repairs. The ministry's reform framework rests on three fundamental pillars: quality-first selection processes, realistic and bankable contracts through upgraded agreements, and enhanced accountability through scorecards, audits, and QR-coded monitoring systems.
The authors, representing BowerGroupAsia, emphasize that these governance improvements should extend beyond highways to address similar challenges in ports, airports, railways, and urban infrastructure. As India advances economic corridors, multimodal logistics parks, and port-led development initiatives, durable infrastructure becomes essential for reducing logistics costs and maintaining global competitiveness.
The reforms signal India's commitment to prioritizing long-term durability over immediate cost savings, establishing a framework that could transform infrastructure development across all sectors and support the country's goal of building one of the world's best road networks.
15
