Gold Outperforms Equities as Indian Markets Show Narrow Participation, Says PL Asset Management
PL Asset Management's latest report reveals Indian equity markets are in a consolidation phase with narrow participation, where resilience comes primarily from limited large-cap stock gains rather than broad-based strength. Precious metals, particularly gold and silver, have outperformed equities due to central bank demand, currency volatility, and geopolitical uncertainty, with Indian equities trading near multi-cycle lows relative to these assets. While sentiment indicators suggest gradual improvement and early signs of returning risk appetite, the firm emphasizes the importance of diversified portfolios until market breadth improves significantly.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Indian equity markets are navigating a consolidation phase marked by global uncertainty, uneven participation, and cautious investor sentiment, according to PL Asset Management's latest PMS Strategy Updates and Insights report. The asset manager highlights that while equity indices have maintained resilience, this performance has been largely driven by gains in a limited set of large-cap stocks, with broader market participation remaining notably weak.
Market Breadth Concerns Persist
The report emphasizes persistently weak market breadth over the past year, with only a small proportion of stocks consistently trading above long-term moving averages. This pattern indicates underlying fragility beneath headline index levels, suggesting that while Indian equities remain fundamentally sound, they have yet to enter a durable, broad-based uptrend.
Style Factor Performance Reflects Selective Environment
Style factor performance in 2025 has reflected the selective market environment currently prevailing:
| Strategy Type: | Performance | Key Drivers |
|---|---|---|
| Value Strategies: | Positive returns | Attractive valuations and earnings visibility |
| High-Beta Strategies: | Positive returns | Measured risk-taking activity |
| Momentum Strategies: | Underperformed | Repeated trend reversals and fragmented leadership |
The performance divergence indicates that while some investor interest exists, particularly in value stocks with relatively attractive valuations, the market has not entered a broad risk-on phase.
Precious Metals Outperform Equities
Against this backdrop, precious metals have significantly outperformed Indian equities during the period. Gold and silver have benefited from multiple supportive factors:
- Sustained central bank demand
- Currency volatility concerns
- Ongoing geopolitical uncertainty
- Industrial usage demand for silver amid supply constraints
PL Asset Management notes that Indian equities are currently trading near multi-cycle relative lows when compared with gold and silver. Such valuation gaps between financial and real assets have historically coincided with periods when diversification helped investors manage volatility and preserve capital.
Sentiment Indicators Show Gradual Improvement
Despite current challenges, market sentiment indicators tracked by the firm suggest that pessimism may have eased. Internal risk and sentiment metrics point to gradual improvement, supported by stable domestic macroeconomic data and a better earnings outlook. The high-low beta spread turned positive toward the latter part of 2025, signaling early signs of returning risk appetite, though recovery is expected to remain gradual.
Strategic Outlook and Portfolio Positioning
Siddharth Vora, Head of Quant Investment Strategies and Fund Manager at PL Asset Management, emphasizes that market outcomes are currently being driven more by asset allocation decisions than by broad equity rallies. He notes that gold and silver have continued to play a stabilizing role during periods of equity consolidation.
Looking ahead, the firm expects Indian equities to benefit from a gradual recovery in earnings and potential global capital rotation as valuations in overseas markets normalize. However, PL Asset Management maintains that diversified portfolios remain important until market breadth improves and volatility moderates. The firm also highlighted that its AQUA (Adaptive Quantitative Unbiased Alpha) strategy demonstrated relative resilience during the recent consolidation phase, marginally outperforming its benchmark in December amid weak market breadth.

























