Bernstein Cuts India to Neutral as Earnings Recovery Already Priced In, Upgrade Drivers Missing
Bernstein has adopted a neutral stance on Indian equities, with Managing Director Venugopal Garre citing already-priced earnings recovery and limited upgrade drivers. The firm projects over 12.00% earnings growth for FY27 and around 13.50% two-year EPS CAGR but warns that margin expansion rather than revenue growth drives these projections. With corporate margins near peak levels and limited policy stimulus options available, Bernstein emphasizes the need for stronger economic catalysts including fiscal stimulus, private capex pickup, or large FDI inflows for meaningful earnings surprises.

*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Bernstein has shifted to a neutral stance on Indian equities, citing limited visibility on earnings upgrade drivers despite expectations of positive market returns over the next year. Managing Director Venugopal Garre explained that while markets have already priced in an earnings recovery following last year's weak growth phase, the absence of clear catalysts for sustained earnings upgrades constrains the scope for sharp outperformance.
Earnings Projections Already Factored Into Valuations
The global brokerage firm has built in robust earnings growth expectations for Indian markets, with specific targets reflecting an optimistic but measured outlook.
| Metric | Projection |
|---|---|
| FY27 Earnings Growth | Over 12.00% |
| Two-Year EPS CAGR (Best Case) | Around 13.50% |
| FY28 vs FY27 Growth | Stronger performance expected |
Garre emphasized that the anticipated recovery is already reflected in current market valuations. "Markets are not looking for recovery anymore—that is priced in. What they are waiting for are drivers of earnings upgrades, and at this point, visibility on those remains limited," he stated. The FY28 growth projections assume favorable outcomes on margins and macro stability.
Margin Expansion Concerns Override Revenue Growth
A significant portion of consensus earnings growth projections for the next two years stems from margin expansion rather than strong topline recovery, according to Garre. This presents a structural concern as corporate margins have already reached near-peak levels across several sectors.
For earnings to surprise meaningfully on the upside, Bernstein identifies several potential catalysts:
- Much stronger overall economic growth
- Fiscal stimulus measures
- Pickup in private capital expenditure
- Large foreign direct investment inflows
However, Garre noted that these factors remain uncertain at present.
Limited Policy Stimulus Options Available
The macro environment presents additional challenges, with incremental data points showing signs of weakening. Interest rates are already positioned close to the peak of the rate-cut cycle, while the government has already implemented several consumption-focused measures in the previous year.
| Policy Area | Current Status |
|---|---|
| Interest Rates | Near peak of rate-cut cycle |
| Government Measures | Consumption-focused steps delivered |
| Trade Agreements | India-US deal facing delays |
| Policy Stimulus Scope | Limited room for fresh measures |
Delays surrounding the India-US trade agreement and uncertainty over its durability add another layer of concern for investor confidence.
Selective Sector Approach Adopted
Bernstein has adopted a selective, stock-specific investment approach rather than making broad sectoral bets. The firm maintains a relatively positive stance on consumption compared to industrials.
Within the financial sector, Bernstein's preferences over a 12-month horizon include:
- Private sector banks: Preferred over PSU banks
- NBFCs: Ranked lower following strong performance in the previous year
Budget Expectations Focus on Fiscal Mathematics
Looking toward the Union Budget, Garre identified the fiscal deficit number as a key variable to monitor, along with the balance between capital expenditure and subsidies. The brokerage does not anticipate further personal tax cuts and believes the government's capacity for aggressive spending is constrained by weak tax buoyancy and nominal GDP growth.
"The challenge is to maintain growth momentum without pulling back too sharply on spending. Flattening the fiscal glide path may be more effective than aggressive consolidation at this stage," Garre explained.
While Bernstein expects Indian markets to deliver positive returns, the firm warns that without strong macro or earnings catalysts, upside potential may remain capped in the near term.












































