DSP Mutual Fund Debunks 12 Major Market Myths in Latest NETRA Report
DSP Mutual Fund's NETRA report systematically challenges 12 major market myths, revealing that gold has outperformed most equities in the 21st century and questioning India's $30 trillion economy projection by 2050. The analysis shows diversified portfolios deliver equity-like returns with lower volatility, while SIP timing has minimal impact on long-term outcomes, emphasizing data-driven investing over popular market narratives.
*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
DSP Mutual Fund has released its comprehensive NETRA report, systematically debunking 12 widely held market beliefs that continue to influence investor decisions. The report challenges everything from gold versus equity performance to GDP growth projections, arguing that investors rely too heavily on myths rather than hard data when making investment choices.
Gold Performance Myths Challenged
The report addresses two contradictory beliefs about gold that dominate current market discourse. Contrary to the popular view that gold is "dead money," 21st-century data reveals a different story:
| Performance Metric | Gold vs Equities |
|---|---|
| Global Performance | Gold outperformed every major stock market in local currency terms |
| Indian Market | Only 25% of NSE 500 stocks beat gold on market-cap-weighted basis |
| Investment Implication | Zero-gold allocation appears more like bias than rational decision |
However, DSP equally dismisses the opposite extreme that gold has replaced equities entirely. Five-year rolling returns demonstrate that equities beat gold approximately half the time in India and the US, with even better performance in Europe and Hong Kong.
Diversification and GDP Growth Reality Check
The fund house's back-testing reveals that a diversified portfolio allocation of 50-20-15-15 across domestic equity, debt, international equity, and gold delivers equity-like returns with significantly lower volatility. This challenges the "di-worse-ification" argument against diversification.
Regarding economic growth projections, DSP questions India's projected path to a $30 trillion economy by 2050:
| Economic Projection | Details |
|---|---|
| Required Growth Rate | 8.9% real GDP CAGR for 25 years |
| Historical Performance | Country has almost never sustained this pace |
| Realistic Outcome | Closer to $20 trillion under optimistic assumptions |
| Long-term Real Growth | Approximately 6% historically |
Investment Strategy Misconceptions
The report systematically addresses several persistent investment myths. Regarding fund performance persistence, DSP's quartile analysis between 2013 and 2025 shows that 60% to 80% of top-quartile schemes slipped into lower quartiles over subsequent three-year periods, with some cohorts experiencing 100% failure rates.
On market timing and SIP strategies, the analysis reveals surprising consistency:
- SIP Starting Points: Seven-year rolling SIPs starting at all-time highs, after 20% rallies, and after 20% corrections showed median outcomes clustered within one percentage point
- Return Range: All scenarios delivered returns around the low teens
- Key Factor: Consistency and time horizon matter more than precise entry timing
Valuation and Risk-Return Relationships
DSP challenges the notion that starting valuations don't matter for long-term investors. Historical Sensex data demonstrates that buying at extreme price-to-earnings multiples can result in decade-long underperformance versus debt instruments. Early 1990s and post-2007 peak buyers experienced bond-like returns with equity-like volatility.
The report also questions the traditional risk-return relationship. Analysis of NSE data since 2007 shows:
| Portfolio Type | Performance Outcome |
|---|---|
| Low-Beta Portfolios | Higher compounded returns than high-beta equivalents |
| Low-Volatility Baskets | Superior performance with shallower drawdowns |
| High-Risk Strategies | Did not guarantee higher returns as commonly believed |
Market Cycles and Flow Dynamics
Regarding small and mid-cap performance, DSP's cycle analysis reveals that while these segments generate significant alpha during upswings, they typically surrender most gains in subsequent downturns. Two-year rolling alpha charts show performance swinging from strongly positive to sharply negative, indicating cyclical rather than permanent outperformance.
The report also addresses flow-driven market assumptions, noting that domestic SIP money and foreign inflows don't guarantee continuous upward movement. Flow data across market cap segments shows that inflows typically surge after strong returns and fade during weak performance periods, suggesting flows follow rather than dictate market direction.
Investment Implications
DSP concludes that successful investing requires moving beyond popular narratives toward data-driven analysis. The fund house emphasizes respecting valuations, maintaining sensible diversification, and filtering out market noise that has proven detrimental to many investors. Rather than seeking perfect forecasts for gold, Nifty, or GDP targets, the report advocates for systematic approaches based on empirical evidence rather than prevailing market sentiment.
20
