Half of India's Most Oversubscribed IPOs Underperform Despite Massive Retail Interest
Analysis shows that nearly 50% of India's top 10 most-subscribed IPOs from the last five years are trading below their listing price, despite initial subscription rates exceeding 100 times. Examples include Vibhor Steel Tubes, Latent View, and Indo Farm Equipment. However, some heavily subscribed IPOs like Mazagon Dock have delivered impressive returns. Recent IPOs such as NSDL and GNG Electronics have also seen declines from post-listing highs. This trend highlights the disconnect between initial investor enthusiasm and long-term market performance, emphasizing the need for thorough research before investing in IPOs.
*this image is generated using AI for illustrative purposes only.
Recent analysis of India's initial public offerings (IPOs) reveals a surprising trend: nearly half of the top 10 most-subscribed IPOs from the past five years are currently trading below their listing price, despite experiencing subscription rates exceeding 100 times the shares on offer. This phenomenon highlights the disconnect between initial investor enthusiasm and long-term market performance.
Underperforming IPOs
Several high-profile IPOs that garnered significant attention during their launch have failed to maintain their initial momentum:
Vibhor Steel Tubes:
- Subscription: 320 times oversubscribed
- Issue Price: ₹151.00
- Debut Price: ₹425.00 (2.5 times the issue price)
- Current Trading Price: ₹152.00
Latent View:
- Subscription: 326 times oversubscribed (most-subscribed IPO in the analysis)
- Current Status: Trading below listing price, but still above its ₹197.00 issue price
Indo Farm Equipment:
- Subscription: 227 times oversubscribed
- Issue Price: ₹215.00
- Current Trading Price: ₹197.00
Retail Investor Enthusiasm
A common thread among these underperforming IPOs is the overwhelming interest from retail investors. In most cases, the retail portions of these offerings were subscribed over 100 times, indicating a high level of enthusiasm from individual investors.
Success Stories
Despite the concerning trend, some heavily subscribed IPOs have delivered impressive returns:
Mazagon Dock:
- Subscription: 155 times oversubscribed
- Issue Price: ₹145.00
- Performance: Over 1,800% returns since listing
Other successful IPOs include:
- Tega Industries
- Paras Defence
- KRN Heat Exchanger
Recent IPO Performance
The performance of some recent IPOs:
- NSDL: Declined 20% from post-listing highs
- GNG Electronics: Dropped 10% from post-listing highs
- HDB Financial:
- IPO Price: ₹740.00
- Peak Price: ₹891.00
- Current Status: Testing its IPO price
Implications for Investors
This analysis serves as a reminder to investors that high subscription rates and strong listing day performances do not guarantee long-term success. It underscores the importance of thorough research and careful consideration of a company's fundamentals, market conditions, and growth prospects before investing in IPOs.
The disparity between subscription rates and current trading prices also highlights the potential risks associated with the initial hype surrounding new listings. Investors should be cautious about getting caught up in the excitement of oversubscribed IPOs and consider a balanced approach to their investment strategies.
As the Indian IPO market continues to evolve, both retail and institutional investors will need to navigate these trends carefully, balancing the potential for high returns with the risks of underperformance in the long run.
15
